Avoid These Cottage Insurance Nightmares

Avoid These Cottage Insurance Nightmares

Burst pipes? Critter damage? Fallen tree? ... Are you sure you know what your cottage insurance covers? Paige Carey of Vasey Insurance Brokers Ltd. and the team at Dawson Insurance Brokers Ltd. tell us their most out-of-the-ordinary claims, most surprisingly common cottage claims, and what you should do about it.


Here's what we asked them: 


  1. What are the most common claims you see in Haliburton County?
  2. What are the most unexpected situations/claims you have come across?
  3. What things you would advise people to take into consideration when insuring their property in Haliburton county?

According to the team at Dawson Insurance Brokers Ltd., the most common claims they experience in Haliburton are: 


Fire Damage - caused by electrical outlets, wood stove fires relating to poor maintenance to the stove and chimney. 
Windstorm Damage - causing trees to fall on dwellings resulting in direct damage to the building and the appliances inside. 


And the most unexpected claims?


Sewage back up - is very expensive to clean up after an occurrence.
Wild Animals - such as bears entering seasonal dwellings looking for food and damaging doors, windows and interior contents. 


The team at Dawson Insurance Brokers Ltd. give this advice for people to take into consideration when insuring their property in Haliburton County. Each insurance company has specific wordings due to vermin entering a dwelling or doing damage i.e. raccoons entering or moving into an attic. Some companies will cover this and others exclude this in their wordings.


They suggest having a review of the replacement construction cost of your home or cottage every 3-5 years. An Insurance policy does provide replacement value coverage providing you have insured your home to replacement value. Your Home or Cottage policy insured limit should be based on construction cost not Tax Assessment values or Real Estate valuations. They also suggest taking pictures or video of your property including interior contents and to keep an inventory of contents and approximate replacement value as your loss will need to be shown in detail to the Insurance Company Adjuster at time of loss. Dawson Insurance Brokers Ltd. welcome the opportunity to be of service throughout the year.

 

We asked Paige Carey and the team at Vasey Insurance Brokers Ltd., Haliburton to educate us on insuring a property in Haliburton County. The most common cause of destruction in our area surprised us - lightning. The granite rock formations in our area apparently attract lightning, and buildings nearby suffer the wrath. 


Talking about anomalies, recently Vaseys processed a claim for a pool that was 'crushed like a pop can' this winter. The cause? An animal of some sort had torn the pool liner causing the water leak, and then froze. Another case of animal destruction was a racoon getting into a boat and causing $9000 in damage, a claim which the insurance company tried to deny - stating vermin were excluded from the policy. The Vasey team went to bat for their client by approaching the local wildlife preserve for the definition of vermin and raccoons and ultimately getting the company to pay up for their client.

 

WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW: 


Every insurance company offers different types of policies and the cottage insurance policies they offer may vary depending on how you use your property. The following are some things you should consider when shopping for the right cottage insurance policy for you:


  • Will you be using your cottage year round or seasonally (for example May to October, and closing the cottage for the winter)? If you use your cottage year round you may qualify for better coverage than a seasonal cottage would. When a cottage is unoccupied for longer periods the risk of loss is higher (burst pipes are less likely to be discovered before doing extensive damage, fires are less likely to be put out, burglary risk increases, etc.) therefore certain coverages may not be included. 
  • Similarly, access to the cottage will be taken into consideration. How far is your cottage from the responding fire hall? Generally, distance from the fire hall impacts your premium. Can fire crews get to your cottage? For example, do you keep your driveway ploughed in the winter or is your cottage located on an island? Discounts may be available to you if you install a monitored fire/burglar alarm.
  • Will you be renting your cottage? You need to consider this when looking for insurance. There are many insurance companies that do not allow rental. Renting may also increase your premium. The increase can vary depending on how many weeks you will be renting your cottage.
  • Make sure you are aware of your options to add additional coverages you may not already be covered for such as theft or vandalism, coverage for any detached structures such as garages, boathouses or bunkies and also consider increasing your limit for contents if necessary. Other optional coverages to consider are earthquake and water damage.
  • Determining the rebuilding cost of your cottage. What you paid for the property is not the amount of coverage you need. For insurance purposes, you are only covering the value of the building itself, whereas the real estate value would take your land or lot into consideration as well.
  • Watercraft: In most cases you can add extra coverage for watercraft to your cottage policy for an additional premium. You should discuss the pros and cons of doing so with your insurance professional. For example, if you insure your watercraft on its own separate policy and someone steals your boat your claim would not affect your cottage insurance policy in terms of your claims free discount.


Paige Carey and the team at Vasey Insurance Brokers Ltd. note that it is extremely important that you are aware of the coverages, exclusions and conditions you have under your policy to ensure you are properly covered. They always recommend you deal with a licensed Insurance Broker for all of your insurance needs. Insurance brokers can find the best company and policy for you, and are always there to explain your coverages to you.

Thank you to the teams at Vasey Insurance Brokers Ltd. and the team at Dawson Insurance Brokers Ltd. for their contributions to this article.


Click here for more great articles from Haliburton Gold Group RE/MAX. 

Learn More

Dark lakeside house with a red roof, white trim, and a small dock by the water, backed by trees.
May 18, 2026
Master the 2026 Haliburton real estate market. Learn how to compare the value of lakes, avoid hidden costs, and secure your dream cottage at the right price.
Lake with autumn trees and a red-roofed cottage on the shore
May 18, 2026
Whether you are selling a waterfront cottage on the Five Lake chain or a year-round home in Minden, the 2026 Haliburton real estate market requires a strategic approach. With rising inventory and more selective buyers, simply listing your property is not enough; you must present it at its best. How to Prepare Your Haliburton Home or Cottage for Sale How do I sell my Haliburton property for the highest price in 2026? To achieve a premium price, transform your property from a personal retreat into a turn-key lifestyle asset. Buyers now prioritize homes that are maintenance-free and visually appealing. By enhancing curb appeal, decluttering, and addressing maintenance, you can reduce days on market by up to 73%. Meet the Haliburton Gold Group At Haliburton Gold Group , we don't just list properties; we enhance them. With over 40 years of combined experience and more than 1,000 local transactions, our team specializes in elevating homes from good to exceptional. Our signature staging and strategic enhancements ensure your property stands out as a top choice for buyers in the Highlands. Impressions Matter: The "driveway moment" sets the tone for the entire showing. Maintenance is Non-Negotiable: Buyers in 2026 are wary of "invisible" costs like septic and WETT repairs. Lifestyle Sells: You are selling the dream of the lake, not just the cabin's square footage. Neutrality Wins: Use high-end neutral tones to help buyers visualize their own life in the space. Maximize Curb Appeal and First Impressions In the Haliburton Highlands, the sale begins as soon as a buyer arrives. Ensure your driveway is freshly graded and clear any overhanging brush. In 2026, nature-inspired landscaping is a leading trend. Use native perennials and local stone to create an entrance that complements the Canadian Shield. Declutter and Depersonalize the Interior Buyers need to see the cottage as their future retreat, not as a collection of personal memories. Remove excess furniture to improve flow and take down personal photos. A minimalist approach makes rooms appear larger and highlights your home's architectural features. Maintenance and Repairs Do not risk losing a sale during inspection. In Haliburton, neglected maintenance can be a deal-breaker. Septic System: Have your tank pumped and baffles inspected. WETT Certification: Ensure all wood-burning appliances comply with code. Water Quality: Service your UV filtration system and provide a recent "potable" water test. Proactive repairs demonstrate to buyers that the home has been well maintained. Optimize Natural Light and Views The view is your most valuable asset. Arrange for professional window cleaning to remove seasonal pollen and lake film. Inside, replace heavy drapes with light-filtering shades. Where permitted, selectively trim shoreline trees to enhance water views and increase natural light. Deep Clean Every Surface A cottage requires a different level of cleaning than a city home. Eliminate any closed-up odours and polish all natural surfaces. Pay special attention to timber frames, stone hearths, and glass railings. A spotless home indicates diligent maintenance. Light Seasonal and Recreational Assets Showcase the lifestyle by arranging Adirondack chairs by the fire pit and keeping the dock free of clutter, with kayaks neatly stored. In your marketing, include photos from all four seasons to highlight the property's year-round appeal, from summer activities to winter recreation. Refresh with Neutral Tones and Minor Upgrades A fresh coat of paint in a sophisticated neutral shade, such as "Highlands Grey," can yield immediate returns. Update outdated hardware with matte-black or brushed-gold fixtures to create a more luxurious atmosphere. These minor upgrades can transform a dated cabin into a luxury retreat. 
Lakeside house with dark exterior and red roof, surrounded by green trees and overlooking water.
February 2, 2026
Discover if year-round private lake cottages for sale in Ontario exist. Explore Haliburton’s luxury winterized retreats, private lake benefits, and expert buying tips.
Interior view of a house with a fireplace, staircase, and large windows.  The RE/MAX Haliburton Gold Group logo is in the foreground.
November 5, 2025
Discover why Haliburton offers the best in Ontario cottage living. Explore the 9 top reasons, from endless water trails to robust Haliburton real estate investment value.
Luxury Living: Why Private Lakefront Homes Are in High Demand in Haliburton
October 20, 2025
Waking up to the serene view of a pristine lake, with a cup of coffee on your private dock as the mist rises and the loons call—this isn't just a fantasy; it's the reality of luxury cottage life in Ontario's Haliburton Highlands.
Haliburton Real Estate: What to Look for When Purchasing Land with a Private Lake
August 15, 2025
Imagine waking up to the serene sounds of nature, with crystal-clear waters gleaming just steps from your door, and the entire lake is yours to enjoy.
More Posts